Gone are the days of the lady with the coiffed hairdo matching her “gorgeous” niece somewhere on Long Island. A few of today’s matchmaking firms are sophisticated organizations with large databases, recruiting teams, coaching systems, and even AI technology to assist matchmakers in achieving the best results for their clients.
We reviewed several dozen firms to identify the leaders in the field, those companies who have established themselves as pioneers in the industry.
In our research, we discovered that matchmaking companies can vary quite significantly in their systems, processes, and the clients they serve (or serve best). For example, some are better suited for older women or seniors, while others might be more appropriately priced for a younger demographic seeking relief from dating apps.
Kelleher International
Founded in 1986 by Jill Kelleher, this San Francisco-based agency has built a reputation for pairing high-profile clients and business executives. Kelleher has established itself as a leader in matching successful and upscale women. Kelleher offers a wide range of matchmaking options that span local, national, and international searches. Clients have the option of working directly with Jill or her daughter, Amber Kelleher-Andrews, depending on their package level.
- Headquarters: San Francisco, CA
- Clientele: Predominantly female, high income, high net-worth, including celebrities and CEOs
- Services: Local, national, and international matchmaking services
- Cost: $30,000 – $300,000+ (depending on the scope of the search)
- Duration: 1 to 3 years, with up to 12 months of “hold” time
- Process: Clients are matched from a database of 50,000 profiles, and higher-level packages include personalized scouting. Coaching is available from licensed coaches
The Standard Agency
The Standard Agency takes matchmaking to an exclusive level, branding itself as a private club rather than a traditional dating service. Established in 2023 through acquisition of several other firms, it has quickly established itself as a favorite among men, including high-profile clients, business executives, and celebrities. Membership is tightly screened, with services tailored specifically for higher income and high-net-worth individuals. With a strong emphasis on confidentiality and discretion, The Standard Agency positions itself as a go-to for those seeking both privacy and premium matchmaking. The company also offers coaching plans to help their clients achieve optimal results.
- Headquarters: Nationwide (private membership)
- Clientele: Predominantly men, higher income. Many high-profile individuals, including celebrities and CEOs
- Services: Nationwide elite matchmaking services using data and human intelligence
- Cost: Customized pricing based on the client’s needs
- Duration: 6 months to 2 years with options available
- Process: Exclusive services for select clients focused on confidentiality and tailored matchmaking to a curated roster of selected singles. Coaching packages available from licensed coaches
Vida Select
Vida Select has quickly made a name for itself in matchmaking. Unlike traditional agencies, Vida Select caters to a broader audience by combining online dating expertise with elite matchmaking services. Vida Select emphasizes efficiency, using a data-driven approach to pair clients with the most compatible matches based on their specific preferences. The service is known for its transparent pricing and modern matchmaking approach, making it a popular choice for busy professionals.
- Headquarters: Nationwide (remote services)
- Clientele: Professionals and high-net-worth individuals
- Services: Online dating assistance combined with traditional matchmaking
- Cost: $695 – $2,895+ per month, depending on the package
- Duration: Month-to-month memberships
- Process: Data-driven matchmaking with ongoing support, optimizing matches based on user feedback and preferences
Selective Search
Selective Search is a highly regarded matchmaking service founded by Barbie Adler in 2000. Based in Chicago, Selective Search serves a national clientele and is known for working with high-profile men seeking long-term relationships. Selective Search uses a combination of executive recruitment techniques and personalized matchmaking to ensure a high success rate. The agency limits its active client base to maintain an intimate, one-on-one approach, focusing on in-depth interviews and personalized service.
- Headquarters: Chicago, IL
- Clientele: Successful men looking for committed relationships
- Services: Tailored matchmaking services with a local, national, or international focus
- Cost: $25,000 – $1,000,000 depending on the scope of the search
- Duration: 12 months, with up to 10 matches
- Process: In-depth interview and creation of a personalized “Benchmarks” document, with feedback provided after each match
Tawkify
Tawkify is a more accessible matchmaking service that operates across the U.S., offering personalized matchmaking at various price points. What sets Tawkify apart is its emphasis on affordability without sacrificing the personalized experience. Clients are matched by a dedicated matchmaker, and packages are flexible to accommodate different budgets. Tawkify’s network spans across the country, making it a viable option for those in areas where other elite agencies may not operate.
- Headquarters: Nationwide (remote services)
- Clientele: Professionals and individuals across the U.S.
- Services: Personalized matchmaking with a large network of singles
- Cost: $3,000 – $70,000 depending on the package
- Duration: Varies by package
- Process: One-on-one matchmaking, with ongoing feedback to refine matches over time
Comparison Table of Major Differences:
| Agency | Cost Range | Duration | Clientele | Location | Process |
| Kelleher International | $30,000 – $300,000+ | 1 to 3 years | High-profile individuals, celebrities | San Francisco (Global) | Matches from a 50,000+ database, personal scouting for higher packages |
| The Standard Agency | Customized pricing | Varies | High-net-worth individuals | Nationwide (private club) | Invitation-only, private, and tailored matchmaking services |
| Vida Select | $695 – $2,895+ per month | Month-to-month | Busy professionals, high-net-worth | Nationwide (remote) | Data-driven, feedback-based matchmaking with online dating assistance |
| Selective Search | $25,000 – $1,000,000 | 12 months | Successful men looking for long-term | Chicago (National) | Personalized “Benchmarks” document and post-date feedback |
| Tawkify | $3,000 – $70,000 | Varies by package | Professionals across the U.S. | Nationwide (remote) | One-on-one matchmaking, flexible pricing options based on individual needs |
Conclusion
Finding the right matchmaking firm ultimately depends on your specific needs, budget, and relationship goals. Whether you seek the exclusive and confidential approach of The Standard Agency, the established reputation of Kelleher International, the data-driven efficiency of Vida Select, the executive-style recruitment of Selective Search, or the accessibility of Tawkify, each of these top firms offers unique advantages.
Premium matchmaking services offer a curated, personalized alternative to dating apps that can save time and emotional energy for busy professionals and high-net-worth individuals who desire the best. As the matchmaking industry continues to evolve, these five companies stand out for their proven track records, innovative approaches, and commitment to helping clients find meaningful relationships in an increasingly disconnected digital world.
